Feeling Computation:
Elemental Media in Jiayu Liu’s Art
2026
- Jussi Parikka
I
This text builds a framework for approaching Jiayu Liu’s art practices and installations as computational culture while asking what computation is. The text shifts back and forth between the idea of computation as digital aesthetic and as a methodological practice – of building immersive, experimental, and experiential worlds of sensing with software, of feeling computation. This points to an interesting proposal: that computation is a way to investigate so-called elemental media of rivers, winds, gravitation, and other natural phenomena. By this I don’t mean we should even metaphorically look for existing digital computing in nature, but expand what we mean by computation as well as cinema too. The sections engage with such questions of information and ecology, as well as projection and natural “screens” as I build an argument about how computational environments become felt and experienced: they envelope the spectator in their synthetic worlds. Philosophically, they raise intriguing ideas: is the work about reproduction or even replacement of nature, or about the disappeared memory of nature and earlier “archives” of artificialisation of nature such as Chinese landscape painting with its controlled brushstrokes, its microcosmos of movements of wind, rivers, and other elemental media.
II
Liu’s art is undeniably entangled with histories and styles of information, even informational art. Does information have a style? Geometric shapes appear and fluctuate on screens and particular hues of screen aesthetics of data surround the spectator. Information glows as electronic light. There is also a lot more at stake, something that concerns the information itself as material. The screens and the installation setup of several of the works are involved in a set of material environments or techniques that are like envelopes. You slip into so-called nature of computational artifice.
In this manner, Liu’s art is undeniably entangled with histories and styles of ecology, even ecological art. Now this claim might be more controversial but as true as the first one. Does ecology have a style beyond the well-trodden tropes of “nature”, “natural”, and by proxy, “non-technological”. This tension produces some of the most interesting digital and media art of past times where the materiality of computational environments are those of ecology. Screens are not limited to technological products, projection and even computation extends beyond the digital computers.
A case in point:
Within Invisibility (2014) returns urban wind data back to offscreen sites as fans blow air into movement, creating mini-atmospheres of air flow. The work is nominally about cities – the data comes from different Chinese locations – but in my view extends into larger questions of landscapes shaped by gradual accumulation of light, weathering, cyclicality, and patterns of physical and chemical forces. Liu herself shifts in this direction as well, referring to the city “as a metaphorical ‘organic computing system’”. However, I want to gently argue that there is no metaphor. Cities compute wind, light, reflections, and movement as they guide such through surfaces, pathways, and other material conditions. Wind and light even construct such surfaces and pathways. The river that flows and shapes the riverbed is a model of computational fluid dynamic – a model that happens to be 1:1 with so-called reality. The computation is “analogue”, not “digital”. Rays, fluids, particles compute pathways, sinks, hotspots, and coldspots. And the same happens in non-urban environments where wind’s relation to energy and information – and thus to the core scientific calculations of the modern world at least since the 19th century – embody a point about computation and nature.
This should not be confused with the tech-corporate version that all is but computation and that cities or landscapes need to be “wired” and datafied. Instead, it links to a deeper philosophical point that also sometimes features in other scholarly literature. One of my favourites is landscape architecture scholar Jane Hutton’s astonishingly rich and productive line – as pithy as it is: “landscapes are models in-situ”. Computational landscapes, too, are models in situ and not only “simulation” of nature or ecology, but as investigation of what computation could be, a point made evident in the discovery of wind that discovers computational landscapes in Within Invisibility.
The keyword is within – a term that is like a fold itself, a wrap that ties two sides of the material into its enveloping feeling.
For sure, digital environments seem more reductive of the abstract material abundance of landscapes that include birds, worms, clouds as much as they do the visual features formed by light. Could computational aesthetics immerse in as rich abundance of sensation, of abstraction that becomes sensed? Consider this proposition with Liu’s artificial landscapes of installations in mind: the flickering (sea)surface of light in Waves of Code, the water cycles of Lakeside Echo, or the brushstroke of a mountain in In the Flow. What I want to suggest is that these are less commentaries on the evolution of technology than an investigation of what is in the first place the artifice of a landscape as light, wind, pulse, movement, perception, and affect.
In other words, I want to claim that a particular strand of Liu’s work is about discovery of computation, by way of computation. This thread of a thought and argument owes itself to an anecdotal discussion with the philosopher of technology Benjamin Bratton, when he asked me if I think computation was discovered or invented. We were at the transmediale festival, in Berlin, a key event for experimental practices and discourses on computational culture. Trained as a historian, of course I would normally have responded that computation is a non-linear multistage invention and in this way also undermining the fallacy that inventions must necessarily be new. The whole invention of invention – as per A.N. Whitehead’s quip in early 20th century – is itself historical.
Bratton was pursuing though a particular point that pops up in other contexts too. Historian of media and sound art Douglas Kahn has argued that radio was discovered, not invented, highlighting a particular natural history of technical media that relates to electromagnetism and many other phenomena of electricity that circuit the globe. Such phenomena of physics though can be said to be made accessible, understood through the media that then piggybacks on them enabling such human-to-human communication and media art as, well, computation and radio. Katherine Hayles has argued that cognition takes place across the spectra of biology, animals, plants, and technical devices. A whole planetary cognitive ecology. Jennifer Gabrys has written about natural history of electronics, highlighting one version of how nature and artifice are folded.
Besides scholars, experimental (media) art practices have been particularly good in focusing on this porous membrane between nature and technology. Some of those membranes become envelopes for sensing.
III
Such questions intersect with contemporary media and art theory, environmental media and humanities, as well as concepts that make sense of the double-bind of computation and ecology. This double-bind goes beyond discourses of “sustainability” without ignoring that either. Climate change is one of the backdrops in Liu’s broader interests too. But as elemental media art, several of Liu’s works investigate what computational methods and digital art can tease out about nature as mediation. It is environmental humanities executed in digital art and synthetic intelligence.
Digital art is rerouted through art historical references, datasets even. Liu’s work is a continuation of Chinese and Western landscape painting. It includes mountains, rivers, and valleys; it includes lakes, and water surfaces, as it does wind and the persistently difficult and delicious problem of representation of wind in visual art. Poet J.R. Carpenter named one of her books aptly: This is a Picture of Wind. It is a book of proxies of wind alongside the poetic writing of and into wind as writing of transformation and observation of weather inside the abstract notion of climate.
Could something similar be at play here? Are these images of plants, water flows, and wind not as representation but as an investigation of the means of representation? Such a means concerns the brushstroke as much as the code line as we shift from classical painting onto digital aesthetics.
Instead of writing, code is indeed a central driver of such worlds of sensing and cognition. Besides language models and generative AI, also p5.js, digital models and rendering fluid dynamics become means of understanding how particular scenes can be both proxies and simulations of nature. There is a good sense of technological critique in Liu’s thinking – such as references to philosopher Bernard Stiegler’s take on the epigenetic media techniques that reorganise sensing. But the computational techniques become themselves modes of sensing in ways that do not replicate the primacy of human sensing being overtaken by “artifice”.
From philosophical discourses we should though zoom in on the actual cultural techniques and workflows of computational imaging and texture mapping that reveals something essential about digital art and aesthetics as practice: datafied worlds are not “generic” and thus less concrete, but that those techniques have to work constantly with finitude and constraints of material environments. What happens on has its double offscreen, in one way or another. This artistic method has thus to stay sensitive to the context of installation, where the digital projection is exposed to the natural transformations of a site, especially if operating outside the white cube of the gallery space. Transition and transference become apt terms for the zones of projection of many of the works from the face of a mountain (In the Flow) to abandoned fossil fuel infrastructures (Treasure of Nature).
In my book A Geology of Media, I have referred to the “medianature” of computational culture. By this concept I wanted to highlight questions of material finitude of digital culture. Computational technologies are reliant on material resources – energy and rare earth minerals for example – while they also are central in epistemic and aesthetic mapping those resources. One part of this relates to the extractivist circuit of corporate technologies, but there is also a more subtle aesthetic possibility there that is also part of Liu’s processual methodology: an aesthetics of elemental media of Wood, Fire, Earth, Metal, and Water. Of waves, gravity, radiation, and projection.
This is an example of digital aesthetics of elemental media, one that exists in some sort of a phantom terrain that is completely real, even if computationally rendered.
IV
There is a really wonderful line in one of Liu’s art works: In Streaming Stillness, she describes the synthetic images trained from existing body of brushstroke movement and textures from Chinese landscape painting.
She writes that the image emerges “from the real world, yet does not belong to it”.
I was left thinking of this and the process of synthesis: the brushstroke itself was already one form of a synthesis but it too was built on top of the synthesis that produced the landscape as natural forces, like I have hinted above. All of it belongs to this world, or this world does not belong to itself.
Perhaps, I thought, there is also a further point bundled in there: such images do not belong to the world because the world in which they are projected has already changed at that very moment of their projection and synthetic imaging. It is not the images that are “unreal” but the world itself that slipped away at the moment of their encounter, transformed and thus not anymore the world that was, but what becomes. Transition and transference, becoming instead of being.
The use of AI in her projects pertains to an inverted sense of the same idea: what training sets have had to be compiled, which data has had to be organized, so that these images have taken place? Which worlds have existed, to become data, so that this particular synthetic reality has taken place? Perhaps it is synthesis all the way to the bottom.
While I am fascinated about software and computation in Liu’s elemental media art, they are undeniably works defined by surfaces and atmospheres of projection. Giuliana Bruno has offered the most comprehensive take on this strand of art and installation methods in Atmospheres of Projection: Environmentality in Art and Screen Media. In Bruno’s take, “environmentality” is not merely about sustainability – similarly as my point earlier – but a particular experiential sense of how cinematic projection works in contemporary art. Of course, in Liu’s texture mapping works, this connection is most intuitive, but I believe it works in similar ways in many of the other immersive installations too.
Projection becomes an investigation of not “content” but the environmental conditions of moving images: the flows across a mountain surface (a cinematic imagination of an ancient submerged land), the flickering of surface and light of the Side Valley, and so forth. Screens persist across natural landscapes, returning the viewer to the same theme I mentioned earlier: perhaps computation and other technical media are discovered, like cinema is discovered across different screens of nature? Aesthetics of information and ecology are supplemented thus with another kind of a strand: that of cinema and projection, one that helps to see the media ecological and computational undercurrent in Liu’s work.
As such, in midst of all the surface screens, there is no depth, there are no “secrets” and hidden realms, there is no transcendental meaning. There are only surfaces: surfaces of screens, materials, water, reflections - surfaces as patterns and data, rhythmic element that inscribe upon a surface that such rhythms make visible in the first place.
I was lucky to get a glimpse to Liu’s new work after I suggested to her that the works build a sense of “living screens”. Her new Living Shell piece (2026) works according to this hybrid mix: LED screens shaped like seashells function as pixel surfaces. They are programmed as generative screens following the principles of cellular automata. John Conway’s mathematical computer “game” example Game of Life (1970) stands as the early example of such a system which showcases emergent behavior: simple rules produce more complex patterns. Liu explains to me how water becomes part of the system: while the pixels are programmed, also “subtle ecological changes” from oxygen bubbles to water currents and variations in light and temperature influence the screen patterns. She calls this micro-intelligence, which I find to be a beautiful term for what I pitched as elemental media and feeling computation. The world is its own training set, a constant process of building, synthetizing, and organizing itself as an image. A rich, complex, abstract and yet embodied world of sensing. Computation that feels its space of potential.
Such computation is felt and sensed as a world full of micro-intelligences, a world full of cognition.
Reference
-
Bruno, Giuliana (2022) Atmospheres of Projection. Environmentality in Art and Screen Media (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
-
Gabrys, Jennifer (2013) Digital Rubbish. A Natural History of Electronics. (Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press).
-
Gil-Fournier, Abelardo and Parikka, Jussi (2024) Living Surfaces. Images, Plants, and Environments of Media (Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press).
-
Hayles, Katherine N. (2017) Unthought: The Power of the Cognitive Nonconscious (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
-
Hutton, Jane (2020) Reciprocal Landscapes. Stories of Material Movements (Abingdon: Routledge).
-
Kahn, Douglas (2013) Earth Sound, Earth Signal: Energies and Earth Magnitude in the Arts (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press).
-
Massumi, Brian (2011) Semblance and Event. Activist Philosophy and the Occurrent Arts (Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press).
-
Offenhuber, Dietmar (2023) Autographic Design. The Matter of Data in a Self-Inscribing World (Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press).
-
Parikka, Jussi (2010) Insect Media: An Archaeology of Animals and Technology (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press).
-
Parikka, Jussi (2015) A Geology of Media (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press).
-
Wickberg, Adam and Gärdebo, Johan, eds. (2022) Environing Media (Abingdon: Routledge).
Originally published in the monograph Signs of Light, 2026
